The Barrier and the Refuge: A Historical Geography of the Sudd

I. Introduction

Few landscapes have shaped the movement of people, armies, and states as much as the great swamp of the upper White Nile, which travelers from the north have called by the Arabic name al-Sudd, “the barrier.” The word comes from Arabic sadd, meaning “barrier” or “obstruction,” and it has come to mean any large floating mat of vegetation. The Nuer and Dinka, who have lived in and around the swamp longer than anyone has kept written records of them, use different words, and their words describe a home rather than an obstacle.[1] That difference in naming is the theme of this essay. Seen from Cairo, Khartoum, Rome, or London, the Sudd was an obstacle that ended navigation, maps, and ambition. Seen from inside it, the same marsh was pasture, fishery, and a defensive moat that protected its people for centuries from the slave raider, the tax collector, and the colonial patrol.

The essay looks at the Sudd from three angles. The first is physical geography: how water, slope, vegetation, and seasonal flooding produce a landscape so hard to cross. The second is human geography: how the Nilotic peoples built ways of living, and political institutions, suited to that landscape. The third is political geography: how outside powers from Nero’s Rome to the present Republic of South Sudan have tried to cross, map, govern, drain, or exploit the swamp. The last section places the Sudd among other “refugia,” a term used here in its human-geographic sense. These are marshes, deltas, forests, and highlands whose difficulty of passage has long protected the people who live in them.

II. Physical Geography: How a River Loses Itself

The White Nile leaves the East African lakes, Victoria and Albert, and enters the territory of South Sudan as the Bahr el Jebel, the “River of the Mountain.” Below the rapids near Nimule and the old station of Gondokoro (near present-day Juba), the river leaves its confined channel and enters a vast, nearly flat clay plain. Between roughly Mongalla and Bor in the south and the confluence with the Sobat near Malakal in the north, the land drops so little over hundreds of kilometers that the river cannot keep a single channel. It splits into a web of side channels, lagoons, and backwaters. The Bahr el Zeraf branches off to the east and rejoins downstream. The Bahr el Ghazal, the “River of the Gazelles,” enters from the west at Lake No, carrying far less water than its huge catchment would suggest, because it too loses itself in swamp.[2]

The defining plant of the permanent swamp is papyrus (Cyperus papyrus), joined by hippo grass (Vossia cuspidata), cattail (Typha), and, since the twentieth century, the introduced water hyacinth. Papyrus roots form interlocking rafts that rise and fall with the water. When floods or wind tear these rafts loose, they drift downstream until they jam in a bend. Over months the jam grows thick enough to choke the channel, and accounts from the nineteenth century describe floating blocks that could hold the weight of a man or even an elephant. Those blocks, the “sudd” in its narrow sense, gave the whole region its name. A boat could be locked in for weeks or months, and crews could find no firm ground to walk out on, no wood for fuel, and no way back.

The other defining feature is evaporation. Spread across an enormous surface under the tropical sun, the Nile gives up a large share of its water to the air. Hydrologists generally put the loss at about half of the inflow, and that figure is the root of every modern scheme to “save” the water by bypassing the swamp.[3] The extent of the swamp also changes greatly. The core of permanent swamp covers at least 30,000 km², but the Nile Basin Initiative describes a wetland of about 60,000 km² that grows by half again in the wet season. Some estimates put the wet-season maximum as high as 90,000 km².[4] When Lake Victoria rose sharply in the early 1960s, the outflow down the Bahr el Jebel rose with it, and the permanent swamp expanded greatly and never fully returned to its earlier size.[5]

Geologists describe the plain beneath the swamp as a series of sunken basins filled with sediment. Those same basins hold the oil fields of Unity and Upper Nile, a fact that has turned the swamp’s edges into strategic ground in recent decades.

The Sudd is best understood not as one swamp but as a set of zones defined by water. Around the permanent swamp lies the toic (a Dinka term), the seasonally flooded grassland that is dry in the dry season and drowned in the rains. Beyond the toic lie slightly higher ridges of sandy soil and woodland, where people can keep permanent homesteads and grow sorghum. This three-part landscape of ridge, toic, and swamp became the framework for the human geography of the region.

III. The Earliest Testimony: The Edge of the Known World

Written sources about the region are few, but they reach back a long way, and nearly all of them come from outsiders who could not get through.

The oldest text that many interpreters link to the upper Nile is Isaiah 18:1–2, the oracle against “the land shadowing with wings, which is beyond the rivers of Ethiopia: That sendeth ambassadors by the sea, even in vessels of bulrushes upon the waters, saying, Go, ye swift messengers, to a nation scattered and peeled, to a people terrible from their beginning hitherto; a nation meted out and trodden down, whose land the rivers have spoiled!” (KJV). The “rivers of Ethiopia” are the rivers of Cush, the land south of Egypt. Commentators have long noted that the “vessels of bulrushes” fit the papyrus craft of the upper Nile, and that the people described elsewhere in the passage as “tall and smooth” (as most modern translations render it) fit the very tall Nilotic peoples. The phrase “whose land the rivers have spoiled,” or divided, fits a country cut up by channels, though interpreters do not agree on whether the oracle has the Sudd itself in view or the Cushite kingdom of Isaiah’s day farther downstream.[6] Zephaniah 3:10 likewise speaks of worshippers coming “from beyond the rivers of Ethiopia.” Read this way, the prophetic texts preserve the oldest memory of a far-off, river-divided people at the edge of the world known in Judah. They also anticipate a theme of this essay: a people both remote and, in God’s purposes, not beyond reach.

Herodotus, writing in the fifth century BC, adds a story of refuge. He reports that in the time of Psammetichus a large body of Egyptian soldiers deserted and marched far up the Nile, beyond Meroë, where they settled among the Ethiopians. He calls them the “Deserters” (Automoloi) and places them as far beyond Meroë as Meroë was beyond Elephantine.[7] Whether or not this story preserves a real migration, it shows that Greeks already pictured the far upper Nile as a place where people beyond the reach of the state could go and remain.

The first clear documentary description of the Sudd comes from Nero’s reign. About AD 61–63, Nero sent a small party of praetorian soldiers under centurions to explore the source of the Nile, possibly as reconnaissance for a campaign. Seneca, who says he heard the account from two of the centurions, reports that they traveled a long way with help from the king of Meroë and the rulers beyond him, and finally reached immense marshes. The inhabitants did not know where the marshes ended, and no one could hope to find out. The vegetation was so tangled with the water that the swamp could not be crossed on foot or by boat, except by a tiny craft holding one person.[8] Pliny the Elder also mentions this expedition. It is a striking fact that the most powerful state of the ancient Mediterranean reached the Sudd, described it accurately, and turned back. Guinness World Records, of all sources, summarizes the result by saying that the swamp’s hostile terrain stopped Nero’s soldiers from pushing the empire further into equatorial Africa.

For roughly the next eighteen centuries, the Sudd marked the practical limit of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern knowledge of the Nile. Ptolemy’s geography placed the source of the river in lakes and “Mountains of the Moon,” and that idea rested on trade reports from the east coast, not on travel up the river. The Christian Nubian kingdoms of Nobadia, Makuria, and Alodia, and after them the Funj sultanate of Sennar, extended their reach southward along the White Nile, but none of them governed the swamp. Above roughly the latitude of the Sobat confluence, the river belonged to the Shilluk, Dinka, and Nuer.

IV. Human Geography: Living With the Flood

Peoples of the swamp

The Sudd and its margins are home mainly to Nilotic peoples. The Dinka (Jieng) are the most numerous and occupy wide stretches of the Bahr el Ghazal and the east bank of the Bahr el Jebel. The Nuer (Naath) hold the central swamp and the land east toward the Sobat. The Shilluk (Chollo) live in a narrow, densely settled strip along the west bank of the White Nile below the swamp proper, and the Anyuak, Murle, and others live on the eastern margins.[9] Their oral histories describe migrations from a homeland in the west or southwest, with the various peoples separating over time. Linguists group their languages together, and their shared customs (cattle naming, initiation by scarification among some groups, cattle-camp life) point to a common origin.

Transhumance and the ridge–toic–swamp cycle

Because the land floods in the rainy season (roughly May to October) and dries out after it, life in the Sudd follows a seasonal movement. In the rains, families live in permanent villages on the higher ridges, cultivate sorghum and maize, and keep cattle in byres. As the floods fall, young men and then whole families drive the herds down to the toic and to the edges of the permanent swamp, where fresh grass grows and fish are trapped in drying pools. In the driest months the cattle camps sit at the edge of the permanent water. When the rains return, everyone moves back up.[10]

E. E. Evans-Pritchard’s classic study The Nuer (1940) argued that this cycle governed even the Nuer sense of time: time was counted in “ecological” seasons and in the tasks of the cattle camp rather than in abstract units. He also argued that Nuer political life, which he called an “ordered anarchy,” was shaped by the land. People were spread out in small settlements on scattered ridges for part of the year and gathered in large camps for the other part. That pattern made a centralized state hard to sustain and favored a balanced system of kin groups that united against outsiders and divided among themselves.[11] Later scholars, especially Douglas Johnson and Sharon Hutchinson, have refined and challenged parts of this picture. They have pointed out that Nuer prophets wielded great authority, and that the “stateless” Nuer of the 1930s were in part a product of colonial conquest.[12] Still, the basic point holds: the physical geography of the Sudd favored mobile, decentralized, cattle-centered societies, and such societies are extremely hard for any outside power to conquer.

Cattle as the center of life

Cattle are the measure of wealth, the medium of bridewealth, the subject of poetry, and the basis of personal names among the Nuer and Dinka. In the human geography of the swamp, cattle also convert the seasonal grass of the toic into milk, blood, and meat, and they move. A people whose wealth walks can retreat into the swamp ahead of a raid in a way that a people whose wealth is stored in granaries cannot. This mobility was one of the main ways the swamp’s refuge worked in practice.

The Shilluk kingdom on the edge

The Shilluk offer a useful contrast. Living on a stable, fertile river bank just below the swamp, they built the only centralized kingdom in the region, under a sacred king (reth) whose seat was at Fashoda (Pachodo, near modern Kodok). From the seventeenth century the Shilluk sent canoe raids far down the White Nile, at times as far as the Funj territories, and they controlled river traffic at the swamp’s northern gate.[13] Their history shows that the swamp edge, not the swamp interior, was where centralized power could take root. It was also where outside states would strike first in the nineteenth century.

The Nuer expansion

In the nineteenth century the Nuer expanded eastward across the Bahr el Zeraf and the Sobat region, absorbing many Dinka and Anyuak communities. Raymond Kelly’s study of this expansion argues that Nuer institutions of bridewealth and kinship gave them a social advantage in mobilizing and incorporating people.[14] This movement took place largely before outside states arrived, and it reminds the reader that the swamp was never a static museum. Its peoples were making their own history before foreign powers entered it.

V. Breaching the Barrier, 1839–1898

The Turco-Egyptian expeditions

The modern history of the Sudd begins with Muhammad Ali, the ruler of Egypt, whose forces had conquered the northern Sudan in 1820–1821. Hoping to find gold and ivory and to settle the old question of the Nile’s source, he sent three river expeditions south under the naval officer Salim Qapudan between 1839 and 1842. In the high-water season these boats forced their way through the swamp and reached the area of Gondokoro. The German engineer Ferdinand Werne, who went with the second expedition, left a vivid account of the passage.[15] For the first time a state from the north had broken through the barrier that had stopped Nero’s men.

Ivory, slaves, and the zariba

Opening the river opened the south to the ivory traders of Khartoum. Within two decades the trade had become a slave trade. Merchants, most of them northern Sudanese, Egyptians, and some Europeans, set up fortified camps (zaribas) with armed retainers, especially on the drier lands of the Bahr el Ghazal to the west and the Equatorial highlands to the south. The richest of them, al-Zubayr Rahma Mansur, built a private empire in the Bahr el Ghazal.[16] Two features of this period matter for the Sudd’s function as a refuge. First, the traders found that the swamp itself was the hardest ground to work: their bases lay mostly on its edges and beyond it, not in its center. Second, the Shilluk on the swamp’s northern edge, the most settled and most reachable people, suffered heavily, with the Turco-Egyptian government establishing a post at Fashoda in 1855 and repeated raids and wars following.[17] The Nuer, deep in the swamp, were raided too but were far less exposed than their neighbors on firmer ground.

Baker, Gessi, and the closing of the river

The Khedive Ismail tried to extend formal Egyptian rule to the equatorial lakes. Samuel Baker, leading a large expedition in 1869–1870, found the Bahr el Jebel completely blocked and spent months cutting a passage, at times taking the expedition through the Bahr el Zeraf instead. His book Ismailia records the effort.[18] Over the following years the government kept the channel open only with constant labor, and when that labor stopped the sudd returned. In 1880 Romolo Gessi, an Italian officer in Egyptian service returning north from the Bahr el Ghazal, was trapped in the swamp with a convoy of steamers and several hundred people. The boats were stuck for months; large numbers died of starvation, and the survivors were reduced to desperate measures before a relief steamer broke through in early 1881.[19] No episode shows more clearly that crossing the Sudd remained possible but never secure.

The Mahdist era: the swamp as a wall

When the Mahdist revolt overthrew Egyptian rule in the northern Sudan (Khartoum fell in January 1885), the Sudd became a wall in the most literal sense. The governor of Equatoria, Emin Pasha, was cut off south of the swamp with his garrison, isolated from Cairo, and only “rescued” (against his own wishes) by H. M. Stanley’s expedition from the Congo side in 1888–1889. The Mahdist state itself controlled the White Nile only as far as the swamp and held only small, short-lived footholds beyond it.[20] For a little over a decade, the swamp once again separated the south from northern power.

Fashoda, 1898

The last act of this period showed how the swamp could serve as a back door as well as a wall. In 1898 the French officer Jean-Baptiste Marchand led a small force overland from the Congo basin, through the Bahr el Ghazal and its swamps, and raised the French flag at Fashoda. There Kitchener, fresh from his victory over the Mahdists at Omdurman, met him with a far larger force coming upriver. The Fashoda crisis brought Britain and France close to war and ended with French withdrawal. It confirmed that the whole Nile valley, the Sudd included, would fall within the British sphere.[21]

VI. The Anglo-Egyptian Condominium: Clearing, Measuring, and Governing

Clearing the river

Under the Anglo-Egyptian Condominium (1899–1956), the first great task in the south was physical: clearing the Bahr el Jebel. Between 1899 and 1904, officers including Malcolm Peake used gunboats, steam cables, saws, fire, and gangs of laborers to cut through the blocks, and the government afterward kept the channel open by regular maintenance.[22] Steamers could now travel from Khartoum to the southern stations on a schedule, and the Sudd stopped being a navigational dead end.

Garstin and the idea of the bypass

The clearing of the river went hand in hand with a new way of seeing the swamp: as a hydrological problem. In his 1904 Report upon the Basin of the Upper Nile, Sir William Garstin, the British adviser on public works in Egypt, measured the losses in the swamp and proposed a straight canal to carry Nile water past it, so that the water lost to evaporation would reach Egypt instead.[23] From that moment the Sudd entered the political geography of the whole Nile basin. Its people became, in planning documents, a population living in the way of Egyptian water.

Pacifying the Nuer

The administrative conquest of the swamp took much longer than the clearing of the channel. The Nuer in particular resisted government control into the late 1920s, with prophets such as Guek Ngundeng serving as focal points. In 1927–1930 the government carried out military operations against them, including the use of aircraft, killed Guek in 1929, and moved some communities into “concentration” areas under the so-called Nuer Settlement.[24] Evans-Pritchard’s research in the early 1930s, commissioned by the government to understand a people it was struggling to rule, took place in the aftermath of these operations.

Southern Policy and the closed districts

From 1930, British “Southern Policy” administered the three southern provinces largely apart from the north. Closed-district regulations restricted the entry of northern traders, Arabic was discouraged, and missions were given the field of education. Douglas Johnson and others have shown how this policy, together with the near absence of development spending, left the south both separate and neglected at independence in 1956.[25] In the Sudd itself, government presence remained thin: a few district posts, chiefs’ courts, and seasonal tours. The landscape still limited the reach of the state.

The Jonglei Investigation Team

After the Second World War, Egypt’s demand for more Nile water revived Garstin’s idea in the form of the Equatorial Nile Project, which included a canal from Jonglei to the Sobat mouth. The Sudan government formed the Jonglei Investigation Team (1946–1954), whose multi-volume report was one of the first major studies anywhere to assess the human and ecological effects of a water project on the people who would bear them. It concluded that a canal would harm the seasonal grasslands, fisheries, and movement routes on which the Nuer, Dinka, and Shilluk depended, and it proposed remedies.[26]

VII. War, the Canal, and Oil: The Sudd in Independent Sudan

The first civil war

The first Sudanese civil war (1955–1972) began with a mutiny of southern troops at Torit in 1955, just before independence, and grew into the Anya-Nya insurgency. Northern forces controlled the towns and the river; the guerrillas held the countryside. The swamp and its flood cycle made conventional operations seasonal, and many civilians retreated from the river posts into the interior. The Addis Ababa Agreement of 1972 gave the south regional self-government.[27]

The Jonglei Canal

In the 1970s Sudan and Egypt agreed to build the canal, and construction began in 1978 with a giant bucket-wheel excavator brought from Pakistan by the French contractor. The excavator cut a straight channel north from near Bor across the eastern margin of the swamp.[28] Supporters promised navigation, development, and new water for Egypt; many southerners saw the project as northern and Egyptian interests taking their water and their land, and there were protests in Juba as early as 1974. By 1984 about two-thirds of the canal had been dug; then work stopped abruptly after rebel separatists, intent on protecting the Sudd, kidnapped the operators. Those rebels belonged to the Sudan People’s Liberation Movement, the same party that later won independence and now governs South Sudan. The great excavator still stands rusting in the swamp, a monument to a project the swamp’s people stopped.

The second civil war and oil

The second civil war (1983–2005) made the Sudd once more a theater of war and a refuge. The Sudan People’s Liberation Army, led by John Garang, a Dinka from the Bor area who had written a doctoral dissertation on the Jonglei Canal region, drew heavily on the cattle-camp youth of the swamp. Oil discovered by Chevron in the late 1970s, at Bentiu and in the Muglad and Melut basins on the western and northern edges of the swamp, turned those margins into battlegrounds. Government-allied militias cleared people from the oil areas through the 1990s.[29] The SPLA split of 1991 brought devastating fighting between Nuer and Dinka factions along the Jonglei corridor. Throughout this period, displaced people repeatedly moved into the deep swamp, where heavy weapons and vehicles could not follow and where fish and water lilies could keep people alive when cattle and crops were lost. Sharon Hutchinson’s work documents how war, money, and the state transformed Nuer life in these years.[30]

The Comprehensive Peace Agreement of 2005 ended the war, and South Sudan became independent in 2011. In June 2006, between those two events, the Sudd was designated a Ramsar Wetland of International Importance, covering 57,000 km². The Ramsar listing names two main threats to the site: oil exploration, since the Sudd holds South Sudan’s largest oil reserves, and the Jonglei Canal Project, then on hold, which would cut wet-season and dry-season flows by 20 percent and 10 percent respectively.

The civil war after independence

When civil war broke out in South Sudan in December 2013, the Sudd’s role as a refuge appeared again in its starkest form. In the fighting that swept Unity and Jonglei states, tens of thousands of civilians, largely Nuer, fled from towns such as Leer into the swamps of Panyijiar and the islands around Nyal. Humanitarian agencies described people living on small islands, reachable only by canoe, eating water-lily roots and fish while armed groups controlled the dry land.[31] It was the same pattern seen in every earlier war, and in an echo of Seneca’s centurions, outsiders found that only a small craft carrying one or two people could reach the places where the swamp’s people had gone.

VIII. The Present: Flood, Dredging, and the Future of the Refuge

Since 2019 the Sudd has expanded sharply after successive years of heavy rain and record high water in Lake Victoria. Around 2.6 million people were displaced in South Sudan between 2020 and 2022 alone: about 1 million by conflict and violence and about 1.5 million by flooding. In 2024, record levels in Lake Victoria combined with heavy rainfall across South Sudan to cause another round of severe flooding. Researchers Liz Stephens and Jacob Levi have asked whether the Sudd is producing the first mass population permanently displaced by a changing climate, with the wetland expanding until former settlements become uninhabitable.[32] The Dinka, Nuer, Anyuak, and Shilluk communities of the Sudd are well adapted to the ordinary rise and fall of seasonal flooding, but the recent floods have exceeded that cycle. Old Fangak in Jonglei has become a town protected from submersion only by mud dykes, and Bentiu’s displacement camp has been encircled by floodwater.

These floods revived the old political geography of the swamp. In June 2022 the South Sudanese government acknowledged that Egypt had delivered equipment to dredge tributaries of the White Nile, and many observers saw this as a step toward resuming the long-dormant Jonglei Canal. The environment ministry opposed both the dredging and the plan to complete the canal, and President Salva Kiir suspended the dredging until impact assessments were done. The East African Court of Justice also issued a restraining order, but South Sudan remains under pressure from Egypt to complete the project. Supporters present dredging as a permanent fix for flooding in Jonglei and Unity. Critics counter that the project mainly serves Egypt and Sudan, and warn that drying the Sudd could bring drought, since the swamp’s moisture feeds rainfall in the region. The debate shows the dilemma at the heart of the swamp’s modern history. The same water that protects its people and feeds their cattle can also drown their villages, and every proposal to tame it is also a proposal to send its water elsewhere.

IX. The Sudd Among the Refugia

The Sudd belongs to a wider class of landscapes that have long protected the people who live in them because they are hard to cross, map, and tax. The political scientist James C. Scott, building on Willem van Schendel’s term “Zomia” for the uplands of mainland Southeast Asia, argued that such regions are not leftovers that “civilization” has not yet reached. They are often places that people actively chose, or retreated into, to escape the reach of states: their taxes, conscription, forced labor, and slave raids. Scott called them “shatter zones” and “zones of refuge,” and he explicitly included swamps and marshes alongside mountains and forests.[33] Placing the Sudd beside its counterparts brings out what these refugia share and where they differ.

The Mesopotamian Marshes. The marshes where the Tigris and Euphrates meet in southern Iraq offer the closest parallel. Like the Sudd, they are a world of reeds and seasonal flooding, home to the Ma’dan (“Marsh Arabs”), who lived on built-up reed islands, kept water buffalo, and moved by canoe. Wilfred Thesiger’s The Marsh Arabs (1964) described their life just before modern change.[34] The marshes sheltered rebels, deserters, and fugitives through many centuries; Edward Ochsenschlager’s ethnoarchaeological work shows ways of building and living there with long continuity.[35] After the 1991 uprising, Saddam Hussein’s regime drained most of the marshes by building canals and embankments, partly to deny the rebels their refuge, and the Ma’dan were scattered. The marshes are the clearest case of what the Sudd’s people feared from the Jonglei Canal: drainage as a tool of state control.

The Great Dismal Swamp. On the border of Virginia and North Carolina, the Great Dismal Swamp sheltered communities of maroons, people who had escaped slavery, from the seventeenth century until the Civil War, along with Native Americans and outcasts. Daniel Sayers’s archaeological work has found settlements on raised “islands” in the swamp interior, occupied over generations.[36] As in the Sudd, it was the deep interior, not the edge, that offered lasting safety.

The Everglades and the Seminoles. In Florida, the Seminoles and the Black Seminoles retreated into the Everglades and the Big Cypress Swamp during three wars with the United States (1817–1818, 1835–1842, and 1855–1858). The United States Army, despite enormous expense, could not remove them all. The descendants of those who stayed in the swamps form the Seminole and Miccosukee nations of today, who have never signed a treaty of surrender.[37] The Florida case shows the same seasonal military logic as the Sudd: troops could campaign only in the dry season, and the water itself defended the people.

Polesie and the Pripet Marshes. In eastern Europe, the Pripet Marshes of Polesie, on the border of modern Belarus and Ukraine, long remained a lightly governed borderland whose people, as Kate Brown has shown, did not fit neatly into the national categories that twentieth-century states tried to impose.[38] In the Second World War the marshes split German operations and sheltered partisans and Jewish refugees.

Other cases. The islands and reed beds of Lake Chad sheltered the Buduma and other island peoples from the slave raids of the surrounding Sahelian states. The mangrove Sundarbans of the Ganges–Brahmaputra delta have long sheltered fugitives and frontier settlers. The Inner Niger Delta and the Okavango, though more open to outside contact, show the same pattern of seasonal flood cycles that shape mobile and decentralized ways of living.

What refugia share

Comparing these cases brings out several common features.

  1. Seasonality as defense. In each case the land is passable in some seasons and not in others. The people who know the cycle can move freely, while outsiders, especially armies with heavy equipment, are stopped for months at a time.
  2. Mobile wealth and diverse food. Cattle in the Sudd, buffalo in Mesopotamia, and fish, wild plants, and small gardens in the American swamps: refuge peoples generally hold wealth that can move and draw on many food sources at once, so the loss of one does not mean starvation.
  3. Decentralized politics. As Scott argued and Evans-Pritchard observed, refuge landscapes favor small, flexible political units over centralized states. Centralized institutions like the Shilluk kingship tend to form on the edges.
  4. Edges are dangerous. In every case, the margins of the refuge, where it meets firm ground and roads, are where outside states strike first: Fashoda and the Shilluk, the oil fields of Unity, the edges of the Dismal Swamp, the fort lines of Florida.
  5. Drainage as conquest. The final answer of the modern state to the refuge has often been to drain it: the Mesopotamian marshes in the 1990s, the Everglades in the twentieth century for farming and development, the Pripet Marshes in Soviet land reclamation, and the Sudd in the Jonglei schemes.

Where the Sudd differs

The Sudd also differs from its counterparts in important ways. Unlike the maroon swamps of North America, it was not mainly a place to which people fled from elsewhere; it was the long-standing home of large populations who simply used its deepest parts as a retreat in times of danger. It is also far larger than most other refugia, which helps explain why no state, ancient or modern, has ever governed it fully. Finally, its recent history shows the limit of the refuge. A landscape that protects by flooding can also destroy by flooding. When the water rises beyond the cycle that people have learned, the refuge becomes a trap. The displaced Nuer and Dinka of the 2020s, crowded onto dykes and into camps on the margins, are living through that reversal.

X. Conclusion

From Isaiah’s “land whose rivers have spoiled” to Nero’s centurions turning back before an impassable marsh, from Gessi’s stranded steamers to the rusting excavator of the Jonglei Canal, the Sudd has stood as one of the great barriers of world history. That barrier has never been empty. For the Nuer, Dinka, Shilluk, and their neighbors, it has been the ground of a way of life organized around flood and cattle, and in time of war it has been a place of hiding when no other place was safe. The pattern recalls the Scriptural theme of the wilderness as a refuge, from David in the strongholds of En-gedi to the woman of Revelation 12:6 who “fled into the wilderness, where she hath a place prepared of God.” The swamp has given its people a place to flee to. Whether it continues to do so depends on decisions now being made in Juba and Cairo about dredging and canals, and on whether the floodwaters return to the cycle that its people have long known how to read.


Notes

  1. On the word sudd and its derivation, see the Ramsar site record for the Sudd (Ramsar Convention Secretariat, 2006) and Collins (2002). In Nuer the swamp is commonly rendered Baki̱ec and in Dinka Toc, the latter term also used for the seasonally flooded grasslands.
  2. The hydrology of the reach from Mongalla to Malakal is treated in detail in Sutcliffe and Parks (1999), chapters on the Bahr el Jebel, Bahr el Ghazal, and Sobat.
  3. Estimates of evaporative loss vary by year and method; Sutcliffe and Parks (1999) and Howell, Lock, and Cobb (1988) give the classic discussions. The figure of about half the inflow is a long-standing summary.
  4. The area of the swamp depends on the definition (permanent swamp, seasonally flooded grassland, or the whole Ramsar site). See Nile Basin Initiative (2023) and Ramsar Convention Secretariat (2006).
  5. On the rise of Lake Victoria in 1961–1964 and its downstream effects, see Sutcliffe and Parks (1999) and Howell et al. (1988).
  6. The identification of the people in Isaiah 18 is debated. Some commentators connect the description to the Cushite (Twenty-fifth) dynasty that ruled Egypt in Isaiah’s time; others see in it the wider peoples of the upper Nile. The papyrus vessels and river-divided land fit the upper Nile in either case.
  7. Herodotus, Histories 2.30. The location of the “Deserters” has been placed by modern scholars anywhere from the Gezira to the White Nile; the essay uses the account for what it shows about Greek ideas of the far upper Nile, not as a fixed location.
  8. Seneca, Naturales Quaestiones 6.8.3–4; compare Pliny, Naturalis Historia 6.181, who describes a reconnaissance by Nero’s praetorians and dates it in connection with a planned Ethiopian campaign.
  9. A full ethnographic survey is beyond this essay; see Evans-Pritchard (1940), Johnson (1994), and Hutchinson (1996) for the Nuer, and Mercer (1971) for the Shilluk.
  10. The seasonal cycle is described in Evans-Pritchard (1940), especially chapters 2–3, and in the Jonglei Investigation Team report as summarized in Howell et al. (1988).
  11. Evans-Pritchard (1940), chapters 3 and 5. The phrase “ordered anarchy” is his.
  12. Johnson (1994) reconstructs the history of Nuer prophets and colonial conquest; Hutchinson (1996) re-examines Nuer society after decades of war and monetization.
  13. Mercer (1971) traces Shilluk trade and river raiding from the mid-seventeenth century.
  14. Kelly (1985).
  15. Werne (1849). On the expeditions generally, see Udal (1998) and Gray (1961).
  16. Gray (1961) remains the standard account of the southern Sudan from 1839 to 1889, including the zariba system.
  17. Mercer (1971); Gray (1961).
  18. Baker (1874).
  19. Gessi (1892). Accounts of the death toll differ; the essay uses general terms.
  20. Moorehead (1960) gives a narrative account; Collins (2002) places Equatoria’s isolation in the context of Nile history.
  21. On Fashoda, see Collins (2002) and Moorehead (1960).
  22. Collins (1990) discusses the clearing of the Bahr el Jebel and its connection to later water planning.
  23. Garstin (1904).
  24. Johnson (1994), chapters on Guek Ngundeng and the Nuer Settlement.
  25. Johnson (2016), chapters 1–2.
  26. Howell et al. (1988) summarize and update the Jonglei Investigation Team’s findings; Collins (1990) gives the political history.
  27. Johnson (2016).
  28. On the canal’s construction and the excavator, see Collins (1990) and Pearce (2022).
  29. Johnson (2016), chapters on the second civil war and the oil fields.
  30. Hutchinson (1996).
  31. Humanitarian reporting from 2014–2016 by the United Nations and Médecins Sans Frontières describes civilians sheltering on swamp islands in Panyijiar County; the essay summarizes this widely reported pattern in general terms.
  32. Stephens and Levi (2024).
  33. Scott (2009), especially chapters 1 and 6. Van Schendel coined “Zomia” in 2002.
  34. Thesiger (1964).
  35. Ochsenschlager (2004).
  36. Sayers (2014).
  37. Covington (1993).
  38. Brown (2004).

References

Baker, S. W. (1874). Ismailia: A narrative of the expedition to Central Africa for the suppression of the slave trade, organized by Ismail, Khedive of Egypt (Vols. 1–2). Macmillan.

Brown, K. (2004). A biography of no place: From ethnic borderland to Soviet heartland. Harvard University Press.

Collins, R. O. (1990). The waters of the Nile: Hydropolitics and the Jonglei Canal, 1900–1988. Clarendon Press.

Collins, R. O. (2002). The Nile. Yale University Press.

Covington, J. W. (1993). The Seminoles of Florida. University Press of Florida.

Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (1940). The Nuer: A description of the modes of livelihood and political institutions of a Nilotic people. Clarendon Press.

Garstin, W. (1904). Report upon the basin of the Upper Nile with proposals for the improvement of that river. National Printing Department.

Gessi, R. (1892). Seven years in the Soudan: Being a record of explorations, adventures, and campaigns against the Arab slave hunters (F. Gessi, Ed.). Sampson Low, Marston.

Gray, R. (1961). A history of the southern Sudan, 1839–1889. Oxford University Press.

Herodotus. (1920). The Persian wars, Volume I: Books 1–2 (A. D. Godley, Trans.; Loeb Classical Library 117). Harvard University Press.

Howell, P., Lock, M., & Cobb, S. (Eds.). (1988). The Jonglei Canal: Impact and opportunity. Cambridge University Press.

Hutchinson, S. E. (1996). Nuer dilemmas: Coping with money, war, and the state. University of California Press.

Johnson, D. H. (1994). Nuer prophets: A history of prophecy from the Upper Nile in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Clarendon Press.

Johnson, D. H. (2016). The root causes of Sudan’s civil wars: Old wars and new wars (Expanded 3rd ed.). James Currey.

Kelly, R. C. (1985). The Nuer conquest: The structure and development of an expansionist system. University of Michigan Press.

Mercer, P. (1971). Shilluk trade and politics from the mid-seventeenth century to 1861. Journal of African History, 12(3), 407–426.

Moorehead, A. (1960). The White Nile. Hamish Hamilton.

Nile Basin Initiative. (2023). Sudd wetland monograph – Volume 1: Overview of the Sudd wetland – Ecosystems and land use (NBI Technical Reports: Wetlands and Biodiversity Series). Nile Basin Initiative.

Ochsenschlager, E. L. (2004). Iraq’s Marsh Arabs in the Garden of Eden. University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.

Pearce, F. (2022, June 22). Will a Nile canal project dry up Africa’s largest wetland? Yale Environment 360. https://e360.yale.edu/features/will-a-nile-canal-project-dry-up-africas-largest-wetland

Pliny the Elder. (1942). Natural history, Volume II: Books 3–7 (H. Rackham, Trans.; Loeb Classical Library 352). Harvard University Press.

Ramsar Convention Secretariat. (2006). Sudd (Ramsar Site No. 1622) [Ramsar Sites Information Service record]. https://rsis.ramsar.org/ris/1622

Sayers, D. O. (2014). A desolate place for a defiant people: The archaeology of maroons, indigenous Americans, and enslaved laborers in the Great Dismal Swamp. University Press of Florida.

Scott, J. C. (2009). The art of not being governed: An anarchist history of upland Southeast Asia. Yale University Press.

Seneca. (2010). Natural questions (H. M. Hine, Trans.). University of Chicago Press.

Stephens, L., & Levi, J. (2024, September 11). South Sudan floods: The first example of a mass population permanently displaced by climate change? The Conversation. https://theconversation.com

Sutcliffe, J. V., & Parks, Y. P. (1999). The hydrology of the Nile (IAHS Special Publication No. 5). International Association of Hydrological Sciences.

Thesiger, W. (1964). The Marsh Arabs. Longmans.

Udal, J. O. (1998). The Nile in darkness: Conquest and exploration, 1504–1862. Michael Russell.

Werne, F. (1849). Expedition to discover the sources of the White Nile, in the years 1840, 1841 (C. W. O’Reilly, Trans.; Vols. 1–2). Richard Bentley.

Yale Environment 360. (2022, July 12). Heeding calls from environmentalists, South Sudan president suspends dredging of Sudd wetland. https://e360.yale.edu/digest/sudd-wetland-jonglei-canal-south-sudan-suspend-dredging


Unknown's avatar

About nathanalbright

I'm a person with diverse interests who loves to read. If you want to know something about me, just ask.
This entry was posted in History, Musings and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply