[Note: The following is the prepared text for a sermon given to The Dalles congregation of the United Church of God on Sabbath, November 14, 2026.]
A couple months ago or so a member here requested that I talk about the subject of polygamy and what the Bible says about it. As a man who is not and has never been close to marriage, at the surface this seems like a puzzling request and that I may not be the ideal person to speak about the subject. Having no personal experience as a husband, and certainly not as the husband of multiple wives, anything I say about polygamy has to come from either a knowledge of the Bible or other applicable law and narratives, or from a personal observation of those who have at least some experience with the institution of plural marriage.
As it happens, I have at least some experience as an observer of this practice. My first understanding of the subject came from my research into biblical history as well as American history, the practice of rulers, and the role of the Mormons in the history of the American west just before the American Civil War. During my twenties, I became familiar with a family whose father was once a deacon within the United Church of God and whose eldest son’s fiance freaked out about the family’s private custom of polygamy, leading to the family being disfellowshipped from the church. More recently, I have seen how some men around the periphery of various churches have desired to be patriarchs of their family in a way that includes plural marriages, and have seen the horror that some young women feel about being sought as a secondary wife.
Since the issue of polygamy is not merely a subject of historical interest, but is something that is actively, if secretively, practiced by people here and now within our own traditions and sometimes even within our own circle of acquaintances, the subject of polygamy deserves to be discussed as the Bible does, so that we may understand the full biblical picture of polygamy in both the Old and New Testament as best as we can. To that end, I will begin this message by talking about what the New Testament, especially the Gospels and pastoral epistles, say about polygamy. After that I will discuss the contrast between the appeal of polygamy to those who (like the historical Mormons or contemporary examples) desire to live like the patriarchs of old, the strict regulation of the practice within biblical law, including its prohibition for kings, and the consistently negative view of polygamy in the narrative sections of the Old Testament, which continually focus on the misery that plural marriage held for women and children in this institution. Finally, I will close by discussing the relevance of the subject to the contemporary church. I hope that after I am done, you may better understand the layers of difficulty provided by those who practice polygamy in the contemporary world and how we can engage with the subject from a full biblical perspective.
Part One: “From the Beginning It Was Not So”
We begin in the Gospels, because that is where we find the most direct statement of Jesus Christ on the question of what marriage was designed to be. In Matthew 19, the Pharisees came to Jesus Christ testing Him with a question about divorce. They asked whether it was lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause. This was a live debate in the first century between the followers of Hillel, who allowed divorce for almost any reason, and the followers of Shammai, who restricted it to cases of serious sexual immorality. Jesus Christ did not simply take a side in the rabbinic dispute. Instead, He went behind the law of Moses entirely, back to the creation itself.
In Matthew 19:4-6 He answered them, “Have you not read that He who made them at the beginning ‘made them male and female,’ and said, ‘For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? So then, they are no longer two but one flesh. Therefore what God has joined together, let not man separate.”
We should notice several things about this answer. First, Jesus Christ appeals to the original design, the pattern of Genesis 1 and 2, as the standard by which later practice is to be measured. Second, the language of that design is singular throughout. A man leaves his father and mother. He is joined to his wife, not his wives. And the two, not the three or the four or the dozen, become one flesh. The Hebrew text of Genesis 2:24 does not include the word “two,” but the Greek translation of the Old Testament that was in common use did, and Jesus Christ quotes it with that word included, and Paul does the same in 1 Corinthians 6:16 and Ephesians 5:31. The point is not merely grammatical. The union of marriage, as God designed it, is a union of two persons into one, and there is no room in that picture for a third.
When the Pharisees pressed Him, asking why Moses commanded a certificate of divorce, Jesus Christ answered in Matthew 19:8, “Moses, because of the hardness of your hearts, permitted you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so.” This principle is one of the most important keys to understanding how the Bible handles polygamy, and we will return to it throughout this message. There are things that the law of Moses permitted and regulated not because God approved of them, but because the people to whom the law was given had hard hearts, and the law met them where they were in order to restrain the damage they would otherwise do. Divorce is the example Jesus Christ gives directly. Polygamy is another example that operates on the same principle. In both cases, the original design “from the beginning” is the standard, and the later permission is a concession to human failure rather than an expression of God’s ideal.
It is worth noting that the world of the first century was not a world free of polygamy. Roman law recognized only monogamous marriage, though Roman men often kept concubines and the practice of divorce and remarriage was very common among the elite. Among the Jews, however, plural marriage was still legally possible and practiced by some, especially the wealthy and powerful. The historian Josephus, writing about Herod the Great, notes that Herod had nine wives at the same time, and comments that it was an ancestral custom of the Jews to have several wives. Herod’s household, by the way, was a byword for murder, intrigue, and suspicion, with Herod executing his own wife Mariamne and several of his own sons. Later Christian writers in the second century, such as Justin Martyr in his dialogue with a Jewish teacher named Trypho, complained that Jewish teachers of his day still allowed men to take four or five wives. So when Jesus Christ and the apostles spoke about marriage, they were speaking into a world where plural marriage was a real option for some of their hearers, not merely a relic of ancient history.
This brings us to the pastoral epistles. In 1 Timothy 3:2, Paul writes to Timothy that “a bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, temperate, sober-minded, of good behavior, hospitable, able to teach.” In verse 12 of the same chapter he says, “Let deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well.” And in Titus 1:6, writing to Titus about appointing elders in every city in Crete, Paul says that an elder must be “blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children not accused of dissipation or insubordination.”
The Greek phrase here is quite compact. It literally reads “a man of one woman” or “a one-woman man.” There has been a great deal of debate over the centuries as to exactly what this phrase was meant to exclude. Some have read it as excluding men who had been divorced and remarried. Some have read it as excluding widowers who had remarried. Some have read it as a requirement that the leader be married at all, though that reading has trouble with the fact that Paul himself appears to have been unmarried during his ministry, and that he praises the single life in 1 Corinthians 7. The most natural reading, and the reading that most scholars would agree upon at a minimum, is that the phrase describes a man who is faithful to one woman, whose life is marked by fidelity to a single wife. Whatever else the phrase may or may not exclude, it plainly excludes a man who has more than one wife at the same time. A polygamist is, by definition, not a one-woman man.
There is a parallel phrase in 1 Timothy 5:9 that helps us understand what Paul means. When discussing which widows should be taken onto the list of those supported by the congregation, Paul says that such a widow should be “the wife of one man.” Now, polyandry, a woman having multiple husbands at once, was not a practice in the world of the first century among either Jews or Romans. So the phrase “wife of one man” was clearly not written to exclude polyandrous women. It describes a woman who had been faithful to her husband, a woman of marital fidelity. The phrase for elders and deacons works the same way. It describes a character of fidelity, and fidelity to one spouse is the core of that character.
Some who favor polygamy today have seized on these passages and argued that if Paul had to specifically require leaders to be the husband of one wife, then by implication ordinary members of the church were permitted to have more than one. This argument does not hold up well when we look at the other qualifications in the same list. Leaders are to be temperate, sober-minded, of good behavior, hospitable, not given to wine, not violent, not greedy for money, gentle, not quarrelsome, not covetous. Nobody would seriously argue that because Paul requires elders to be not violent and not greedy, that ordinary members are therefore permitted to be violent and greedy. The qualifications for leaders are not a special code of conduct that applies only to a clerical class. They describe the mature Christian character that leaders are required to model, so that the rest of the congregation may follow it. Peter makes this explicit in 1 Peter 5:3, telling elders not to lord it over those entrusted to them but to be examples to the flock. Paul tells the Corinthians in 1 Corinthians 11:1 to imitate him as he imitates Christ. The leader’s household is meant to be a model household. If the model household of the church is one husband with one wife, then the church is being shown what all households are meant to look like.
There is also a practical and pastoral wisdom in why Paul framed the requirement in this way, and it is a wisdom that missionaries throughout history have had to rediscover. When the gospel spread into societies where polygamy was common, men who already had multiple wives sometimes came to repentance and baptism. What were they to do? If such a man were to divorce all of his wives but one, he would be casting off women who had done nothing wrong and who, in those societies, would often be left destitute and without protection, along with their children. That would compound one wrong with another. The approach that many thoughtful missionaries took, and the approach that seems consistent with Paul’s instructions, was that such a man was not required to abandon the wives and children he had already taken on, for whom he had obligations, but that he was not to take any more, and he could not serve as an elder or deacon. In this way the church protected the women and children who were already vulnerable, while making it unmistakably clear in its leadership what the standard was going forward. Paul’s instructions to Timothy and Titus, written to congregations in a world where plural marriage still existed in some households, fit this situation exactly.
Beyond the pastoral epistles, Paul’s broader teaching on marriage points the same way. In 1 Corinthians 7:2 he writes, “Nevertheless, because of sexual immorality, let each man have his own wife, and let each woman have her own husband.” The symmetry here is striking. Each man has his own wife; each woman has her own husband. In verses 3 and 4 he continues: “Let the husband render to his wife the affection due her, and likewise also the wife to her husband. The wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does. And likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does.” This mutual authority, this mutual belonging, is impossible in a polygamous household. If a wife has authority over her husband’s body, then her husband’s body cannot belong to another wife at the same time without her rights being diminished. The very logic of the mutual obligations Paul describes assumes a union of one man and one woman.
The New Testament, then, is consistent. Jesus Christ points us back to the beginning, where one man is joined to one wife and the two become one flesh. Paul requires the leaders of the church, who are to be examples to all, to be one-woman men. And the mutual obligations of husbands and wives in 1 Corinthians 7 are framed in a way that only makes sense in a monogamous union. The New Testament does not need to thunder against polygamy in every chapter because its picture of marriage simply leaves no room for it.
Part Two: The Law, the Patriarchs, and the Appeal of the Tent
If the New Testament is so clear, why does polygamy continue to attract people who claim to take the Bible seriously? The answer, in large part, is the example of the patriarchs. Abraham, the father of the faithful, had Sarah and Hagar and later Keturah, along with concubines. Jacob, whose name became Israel, had four women who bore him the twelve sons who became the tribes of Israel. David, the man after God’s own heart, had many wives. If these men were friends of God, the argument goes, and if God blessed them and never explicitly condemned them for their plural marriages, then how can plural marriage be wrong? And if we are to live by every word of God, as so many of us in this tradition rightly insist, why should we reject a practice that the fathers of our faith followed?
This line of reasoning has a long history in America, and it is worth spending some time on that history, because it shows us what happens when people build a way of life on the example of the patriarchs while ignoring what the rest of the Bible says about that example. In the 1830s and early 1840s, Joseph Smith, the founder of the Latter Day Saint movement, began privately teaching and practicing what his followers called plural marriage. In 1843 he recorded a revelation, later published as section 132 of the Doctrine and Covenants, which explicitly appealed to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, David, and Solomon as examples of men who received wives from God. The practice was kept secret for some years and officially denied, but after the Mormons moved west to the Great Basin, the church publicly announced the doctrine in 1852.
The reaction in the rest of the United States was fierce. In 1856, the newly formed Republican Party, in its first national platform, called on Congress to prohibit in the territories what it called the “twin relics of barbarism,” polygamy and slavery. It is worth pausing to notice the company that polygamy was keeping in the minds of Americans of that time. Both institutions were seen as forms of domination in which some human beings were held under the control of others in ways that were incompatible with a free and Christian society. Both institutions also had their defenders who appealed to the patriarchs of the Bible. Congress passed the Morrill Anti-Bigamy Act in 1862, in the middle of the Civil War, and the Supreme Court upheld the federal prohibition of polygamy in Reynolds versus United States in 1879. After further federal legislation in the 1880s that disenfranchised polygamists and threatened the church’s property, the president of the church, Wilford Woodruff, issued a manifesto in 1890 advising members to stop contracting plural marriages. The mainstream church eventually abandoned the practice, but a number of fundamentalist groups broke away and continued it, and some of them continue it to this day.
The fruit of those fundamentalist communities has been well documented. Because the arithmetic of polygamy does not work out evenly, with roughly equal numbers of boys and girls born, a system where some men take many wives requires that many other men take none. In some of these communities, teenage boys have been pushed out of their homes and their communities, the so-called “lost boys,” so that older and more powerful men would face less competition for young women. Girls have been married off very young to much older men, often as additional wives to men who were already married. The leader of one of the largest of these groups was convicted in 2011 of crimes related to his so-called marriages with underage girls. These things did not happen by accident. They are the predictable consequences of a system in which men with power gather women to themselves, and they are exactly the kinds of consequences that the Bible itself warns about.
What is troubling for us is that this pattern of reasoning is not limited to Mormons or their offshoots. In recent decades there have been small movements among some conservative Protestants, some people in Hebrew Roots circles, and yes, some people on the margins of the Sabbatarian churches, who have argued that plural marriage is “biblical” and that the modern church’s rejection of it is a Gentile or Roman tradition that ought to be cast off. The appeal is often wrapped up in the language of patriarchy and restoration, of returning to the way of life of the fathers, of men taking up their rightful role as heads of large households. It can sound very pious. But we need to examine it carefully, because the Bible itself examines it carefully.
The first thing to notice is the difference between description and prescription. The Bible describes a great many things that people did without approving of them. It describes Abraham lying about Sarah being his sister, twice. It describes Isaac doing the same thing with Rebekah. It describes Jacob deceiving his father to obtain a blessing. It describes Judah going in to a woman he took to be a prostitute. It describes David committing adultery and murder. Nobody would argue that because these things are recorded about godly men, they are therefore models for us to follow. The patriarchs were men of faith, and Hebrews 11 commends them for their faith, but their faith did not make every action they took a pattern for us. The question is not whether the patriarchs had multiple wives. Clearly they did. The question is how the Bible itself evaluates what happened as a result.
The second thing to notice is how the law of Moses treats polygamy. The law does not command it anywhere. Instead, it regulates it, and the regulations are consistently aimed at protecting the vulnerable parties, particularly the wives who were less favored and their children.
Exodus 21:10 says, concerning a man who has taken a servant woman as a wife and then takes another: “If he takes another wife, he shall not diminish her food, her clothing, and her marriage rights.” The concern of the law here is the woman who is likely to be neglected once a newer wife arrives. The law requires that she not be cheated of her provision or her rights as a wife. The very existence of this regulation shows that the law anticipated what would naturally happen in a plural marriage: the first wife would be pushed aside.
Deuteronomy 21:15-17 addresses another predictable problem: “If a man has two wives, one loved and the other unloved, and they have borne him children, both the loved and the unloved, and if the firstborn son is of her who is unloved, then it shall be, on the day he bequeaths his possessions to his sons, that he must not bestow firstborn status on the son of the loved wife in preference to the son of the unloved, the true firstborn. But he shall acknowledge the son of the unloved wife as the firstborn by giving him a double portion of all that he has.” Notice how the law simply assumes that in a household with two wives, one will be loved and the other unloved. That is not presented as an unusual situation but as the expected one. And the law steps in to protect the children of the unloved wife from being robbed of their inheritance because of their father’s favoritism. Anyone who knows the story of Jacob, Leah, Rachel, and Joseph will hear the echo of that story in this law.
Leviticus 18:18 prohibits a man from taking a woman as a rival to her sister, to uncover her nakedness while the sister is still alive. The Hebrew word translated “rival” captures exactly what plural marriage tends to produce: rivalry, vexation, and distress between the women involved. Again, this law reads like a commentary on Jacob’s marriage to the two sisters Leah and Rachel. Interestingly, some Jewish interpreters in the period before Jesus Christ, including the authors of some of the texts found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, read this law, along with Genesis 1:27, as a prohibition of plural marriage in general, and condemned those who took a second wife while the first was living. Whether or not that was the original intent of Leviticus 18:18, it shows that thoughtful Jewish readers before the time of Jesus Christ already saw the trajectory of the law as pointing away from polygamy.
Most striking of all is Deuteronomy 17:17, in the law of the king. Moses, anticipating that Israel would one day want a king like the nations around them, gave instructions for what that king must and must not do. Among them: “Neither shall he multiply wives for himself, lest his heart turn away; nor shall he greatly multiply silver and gold for himself.” The king, the one man in Israel with the power and wealth to gather the most wives to himself, is specifically forbidden from doing so. And the reason given is spiritual: lest his heart turn away. The law places the multiplication of wives alongside the multiplication of horses and gold as the typical temptations of a man with power, temptations that would turn his heart from God.
We know how that warning played out. First Kings 11:1-4 tells us that King Solomon loved many foreign women, and that he had seven hundred wives, princesses, and three hundred concubines, “and his wives turned away his heart.” When Solomon was old, his wives turned his heart after other gods, and his heart was not loyal to the Eternal his God as was the heart of his father David. The exact consequence that Deuteronomy 17 warned about came to pass in the wisest man who ever lived. Centuries later, after the return from exile, Nehemiah would point to Solomon as a warning to the people of his own day in Nehemiah 13:26: “Did not Solomon king of Israel sin by these things? Yet among many nations there was no king like him, who was beloved of his God; and God made him king over all Israel. Nevertheless pagan women caused even him to sin.”
So the law of Moses presents a consistent picture. Plural marriage existed among the Israelites as it existed among the nations around them. The law did not command it, did not praise it, and did not hold it up as an ideal. Instead, the law fenced it in, protecting the wives who would inevitably be neglected and the children who would inevitably be cheated, and forbidding it outright for the one man in Israel most able to indulge in it. This is precisely the same way that the law handled divorce, which God says in Malachi 2:16 that He hates. The law regulated what it did not approve, because of the hardness of men’s hearts, and pointed back toward the original design.
Part Three: What the Stories Remember
If the law regulates polygamy, the narratives of the Old Testament do something more. They show us, again and again and again, what plural marriage actually did to the people who lived inside it. And what is remarkable is that there is not one single polygamous household in the Bible that is presented as happy and at peace. Not one. When we read the stories carefully, we find that the biblical writers consistently focus on the misery of plural marriage, and they focus especially on the suffering of the women and children involved.
The first polygamist in the Bible is Lamech, in Genesis 4:19-24. He is a descendant of Cain, the first murderer, and he is the first man recorded as taking two wives, Adah and Zillah. What is the only thing we hear Lamech say? He calls his two wives together to boast to them that he has killed a man for wounding him, and that if Cain is avenged sevenfold, then Lamech will be avenged seventy-sevenfold. The first plural marriage in Scripture appears in the line of Cain, in the person of a violent and boastful man, in a passage that describes the spread of human pride and violence before the flood. That is not an accident of placement. The text is telling us something about where this practice comes from.
Then we come to Abraham. Sarah, despairing of having children of her own, gives her servant Hagar to Abraham as a wife, in Genesis 16. This was in keeping with the customs of the time, as we know from ancient Near Eastern contracts. But what happened? As soon as Hagar conceived, she despised her mistress. Sarah then blamed Abraham, saying in Genesis 16:5, “My wrong be upon you!” Abraham handed the matter back to Sarah, and Sarah dealt so harshly with Hagar that Hagar fled into the wilderness while pregnant. Years later, after Isaac was born, the conflict broke out again, and Hagar and her son Ishmael were sent away into the wilderness with a skin of water and some bread. The rivalry between the descendants of those two sons has continued in various forms down to our own day.
And yet notice where God’s attention goes in this story. When Hagar fled into the wilderness, the Angel of the Eternal found her by a spring of water and spoke to her. Hagar, a foreign slave woman used as a means to an end, became the first person in the Bible to give God a name. In Genesis 16:13 she called Him “You-Are-the-God-Who-Sees,” for she said, “Have I also here seen Him who sees me?” When she and her son were later cast out and the water ran out, God heard the voice of the boy and opened Hagar’s eyes to see a well. The people who are wronged by the plural marriage are the people God goes looking for.
Even Isaac’s household was touched by this. Genesis 26:34-35 tells us that when Esau was forty years old he took two Hittite wives, Judith and Basemath, “and they were a grief of mind to Isaac and Rebekah.” Esau later added a third wife, a daughter of Ishmael, in a clumsy attempt to please his parents. The man who despised his birthright is the man who multiplied his wives.
Then we come to Jacob, whose household is the most fully described polygamous household in all of Scripture. Jacob loved Rachel and worked seven years for her, only to be deceived by her father Laban into marrying her older sister Leah first. He then worked another seven years for Rachel. Genesis 29:30 tells us plainly that he loved Rachel more than Leah. And verse 31 tells us, “When the Eternal saw that Leah was unloved, He opened her womb.” Once again, God’s eye is on the one who suffers.
Listen to how Leah named her sons, because the names tell her story. Her firstborn she named Reuben, saying in Genesis 29:32, “The Eternal has surely looked on my affliction. Now therefore, my husband will love me.” Her second she named Simeon, saying, “Because the Eternal has heard that I am unloved, He has therefore given me this son also.” Her third she named Levi, saying, “Now this time my husband will become attached to me, because I have borne him three sons.” Can we hear the heartbreak in those words? Each child is a desperate hope that this time, at last, her husband will love her. Only with her fourth son, Judah, does she turn her attention away from her husband and say simply, “Now I will praise the Eternal.”
Meanwhile Rachel, the loved wife, was barren, and she envied her sister. In Genesis 30:1 she said to Jacob, “Give me children, or else I die!” and Jacob’s anger was kindled against her. She gave him her maid Bilhah, and named Bilhah’s second son Naphtali, saying, “With great wrestlings I have wrestled with my sister, and indeed I have prevailed.” Leah responded by giving Jacob her own maid Zilpah. The sisters even bargained over their husband, with Rachel trading a night with Jacob to Leah for some mandrakes that Leah’s son Reuben had found. Four women, two of them sisters, two of them servants with no say in the matter, all competing for one man’s attention and affection, using their children as weapons and trophies in the competition.
And what happened to the children? Jacob’s favoritism toward Rachel passed down to Rachel’s son Joseph. He made Joseph a tunic of many colors, and the brothers hated Joseph so much that they could not speak peaceably to him. Eventually they sold him into slavery and told their father he was dead, and Jacob mourned for years. Reuben, Leah’s firstborn, went in to Bilhah, his father’s concubine, and lost his birthright because of it. Simeon and Levi slaughtered the men of Shechem. The household of Israel, the family that became a nation, was a household torn by envy, favoritism, sexual sin, violence, and deceit, and the roots of that dysfunction are laid down plainly in the rivalry of the wives.
The pattern continues into the period of the judges. Gideon, who refused to be king, nonetheless lived like one. Judges 8:30-31 tells us that he had seventy sons, for he had many wives, and that his concubine in Shechem bore him a son named Abimelech. After Gideon’s death, Abimelech, the son of the concubine, hired worthless and reckless men and murdered his seventy half-brothers on one stone, with only the youngest, Jotham, escaping. The son of the secondary woman, perhaps resentful of his lower status, wiped out the sons of the primary wives. The household of many wives became a slaughterhouse.
At the beginning of 1 Samuel, we meet Elkanah, a godly man from Ephraim, who had two wives, Hannah and Peninnah. Peninnah had children and Hannah had none. First Samuel 1:6-7 tells us that Peninnah, whom the text calls Hannah’s rival, provoked her severely to make her miserable, year after year, whenever they went up to the house of the Eternal, so that Hannah wept and did not eat. Elkanah, loving Hannah, asked her in verse 8, “Hannah, why do you weep? Why do you not eat? And why is your heart grieved? Am I not better to you than ten sons?” It is a touching question, but it also shows that he did not understand at all what she was suffering. Once again the text keeps its focus on the suffering woman, and once again God hears her prayer, giving her Samuel.
And then there is David. David is a man after God’s own heart, but he multiplied wives exactly as Deuteronomy 17 had warned against, gathering wives and concubines in Hebron and later in Jerusalem. What came of David’s household? His eldest son Amnon, son of Ahinoam, raped his half-sister Tamar, daughter of Maacah. Tamar’s full brother Absalom waited two years and then murdered Amnon. Absalom later rebelled against David, drove him from Jerusalem, and publicly went in to his father’s concubines on the roof of the palace, fulfilling the judgment of 2 Samuel 12:11. Absalom was killed in the rebellion. As David lay dying, his son Adonijah, son of Haggith, tried to seize the throne, and was eventually executed by Solomon, son of Bathsheba. A household of half-brothers born to rival mothers turned into a household of rape, fratricide, rebellion, and execution. The multiplication of David’s wives became the division of David’s sons.
Then we come again to Solomon, whose seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines turned his heart away from God, and whose idolatry led directly to the division of the kingdom after his death. His son Rehoboam, according to 2 Chronicles 11:21, had eighteen wives and sixty concubines, and loved Maachah more than all his other wives, making her son the chief among his brothers. The pattern of favoritism and division simply repeated itself in the next generation.
Even when we look at a foreign king like Ahasuerus in the book of Esther, the picture is grim. His harem was filled by gathering all the beautiful young virgins of his kingdom, and once a woman went in to the king she passed into the house of the concubines and did not come back to him unless he delighted in her and called her by name. Esther herself feared to approach her own husband unsummoned, because to do so could mean death. Vashti was deposed for refusing to be displayed before the king’s drunken guests. Plural marriage at the royal level reduced women to possessions to be gathered, used, and set aside at a king’s whim.
When we put all of these stories together, the verdict of the biblical narrative is overwhelming. The writers of Scripture rarely pause to give an explicit moral condemnation of plural marriage, but they do not need to. They simply tell us what happened, and what happened is always the same: rivalry between wives, envy, contempt, favoritism, neglected women weeping, children competing for inheritance and attention, half-brothers hating and killing each other, and the hearts of men turned away from God. And throughout these stories, the eye of God is repeatedly drawn to the woman who suffers: to Hagar in the wilderness, to Leah who was unloved, to Hannah weeping at the tabernacle. Those who look at the patriarchs and see an attractive model of household life are not reading the stories the way the Bible tells them. They are seeing themselves in the place of the patriarch at the center of the tent, and not seeing themselves in the place of Leah, or Hagar, or Hannah, or Joseph in the pit, or Tamar desolate in her brother’s house.
Part Four: One Bridegroom, One Bride
Having looked at the New Testament, the law, and the narratives, we must now ask why any of this matters for the gospel itself. The answer is that marriage in Scripture is never only about marriage. From the very beginning, the union of a man and a woman was designed to picture something greater.
Paul makes this explicit in Ephesians 5. After telling husbands to love their wives just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself for her, he quotes Genesis 2:24 once more, “For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh,” and then says in verse 32, “This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church.” The union of one man and one woman in marriage is a living picture of the union between Jesus Christ and His people. And Jesus Christ does not have many brides. He has one. In 2 Corinthians 11:2, Paul tells the Corinthians, “For I have betrothed you to one husband, that I may present you as a chaste virgin to Christ.” In Revelation 19:7, the great multitude cries out, “Let us be glad and rejoice and give Him glory, for the marriage of the Lamb has come, and His wife has made herself ready.” In Revelation 21, the holy city, New Jerusalem, comes down out of heaven, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. One bridegroom, one bride.
This is why the question of polygamy is not a minor matter of household arrangement. If marriage is meant to be a picture of the relationship between Jesus Christ and the church, then a plural marriage paints a false picture. It suggests a God who divides His love among rival brides, who favors one and neglects another, whose people must compete with each other for His attention. That is not the gospel. The gospel is the story of a bridegroom who gives Himself completely for one bride, who loves her wholly and is wholly hers, and who calls her into a union where there is no rival.
There is a fascinating passage in the prophets that, at first glance, seems to point the other way. In Ezekiel 23, God speaks of two sisters, Oholah and Oholibah, representing Samaria and Jerusalem, and says that they were His. Jeremiah 3 uses similar imagery of faithless Israel and treacherous Judah. Someone might seize on this and say that God Himself is pictured with two wives. But look carefully at what these passages describe. The two sisters exist because the one people of God was divided after the death of Solomon, the very division that grew out of Solomon’s multiplied wives. And the story of these two sisters is a story of unfaithfulness, rivalry, and judgment, a story every bit as miserable as the stories of the polygamous households in Genesis and Samuel. The picture of God with two wives is a picture of something broken. And what is God’s answer to that brokenness? In Ezekiel 37:15-22, God tells the prophet to take two sticks, one for Judah and one for Joseph, and join them together so that they become one stick in his hand. “I will make them one nation in the land, on the mountains of Israel; and one king shall be king over them all; they shall no longer be two nations, nor shall they ever be divided into two kingdoms again.” Even where God’s relationship with His people is pictured as plural, the plurality is the result of sin and division, and the promise of restoration is a promise of unity. The many become one. That is the direction of God’s plan.
This gospel picture has direct consequences for how God’s people treat women and children. Throughout the biblical record, as we have seen, plural marriage consistently degrades the position of women. It turns wives into rivals. It leaves some wives unloved and others merely used. It makes servant women into breeding stock, as with Bilhah and Zilpah, who were given to Jacob without their consent and whose children were named by their mistresses. It requires that some women be gathered by powerful men while other men go without, and in our own time it has meant girls married off young to men who already have wives. It makes children into competitors for inheritance and affection, and it breeds hatred between half-brothers.
Against this, the biblical vision of marriage consistently elevates the dignity of the wife. Malachi 2:14-15 rebukes the men of Judah for dealing treacherously with the wife of their youth, and calls her “your companion and your wife by covenant.” The prophet then asks, “But did He not make them one, having a remnant of the Spirit? And why one? He seeks godly offspring.” The oneness of husband and wife is tied directly to the raising of godly children. Proverbs 5:18 tells a man to rejoice with the wife of his youth. Proverbs 31 praises a single excellent wife whose husband trusts her completely and whose children rise up and call her blessed. Psalm 128 pictures the blessed man with his wife like a fruitful vine in the very heart of his house and his children like olive plants all around his table. And in the New Testament, Peter tells husbands in 1 Peter 3:7 to dwell with their wives with understanding, giving honor to the wife as being heirs together of the grace of life, that their prayers may not be hindered. Heirs together. Not a hierarchy of first wife and second wife and concubine, but a husband and a wife who share together in the inheritance of God’s kingdom.
The direction of Scripture, from the regulations of the law that protected the unloved wife and her children, through the narratives that keep their eye on Hagar and Leah and Hannah, to the New Testament insistence that leaders be one-woman men and that husbands honor their wives as fellow heirs, is a direction that consistently aims at the improvement of the lives of women and children. God has always been on the side of the one who is pushed aside.
Part Five: Why It Still Appeals, and What We Must Do
And yet, despite all of this, polygamy remains appealing to a certain type of man, even now, even among those who read the Bible. Why is this?
I think we have to be honest about the answer. The appeal of plural marriage has very little to do with careful study of Scripture and a great deal to do with the desires of the human heart. James 4:1 asks, “Where do wars and fights come from among you? Do they not come from your desires for pleasure that war in your members?” The desire to be a patriarch at the center of a large household, admired and obeyed by multiple wives, surrounded by many children, is at bottom a desire for status, for control, and for the gratification of appetite. It is the same desire that drove Lamech to boast, that drove Gideon to live like a king, that drove David to gather wives in Hebron and Solomon to gather a thousand women in Jerusalem. It is exactly the temptation that Deuteronomy 17 warned the king about, because it is the temptation that power naturally produces. The scriptural language of patriarchy and restoration can be a cover for something much older and much less holy.
It is also worth noticing who finds this idea appealing and who does not. In my experience, it is men who are drawn to it, sometimes men who feel that they have not received the respect or the position they believe they deserve, and who imagine that a household of many wives would give it to them. It is very rarely the women who find it appealing. The horror that some young women feel when they discover that they are being sought as a secondary wife is not a sign of their lack of faith or their captivity to modern culture. It is a righteous instinct, and it is the same instinct that the biblical narratives honor when they give us the voices of Leah and Hannah. Those young women are seeing the situation from the place where the Bible tells us to look.
So what should we, as a congregation, do with all of this?
First, we must not be naive. The family I mentioned at the beginning of this message was a family of people who were respected, who served in the church, and whose private practice remained hidden until a young woman who was about to marry into the family discovered it and was horrified. Polygamy in our time is usually practiced in secret, precisely because those who practice it know that the law of the land and the teaching of the church are against it. Those of us who have responsibility for young people, and especially for young women, need to be aware that there are men around the edges of churches like ours who are looking for exactly this, and who will often present it in the language of Scripture and patriarchy. We should not be surprised by it, and we should be ready to answer it.
Second, we must protect the vulnerable. When a young woman comes to someone in this congregation troubled because she is being approached as a prospective second wife, she deserves to be believed, supported, and protected, not pressured or told that her discomfort is a lack of faith. Our concern must be the same as the concern of the law in Exodus 21 and Deuteronomy 21, which was to protect the women and children who would otherwise be harmed. And where women and children are already living within such households, our concern must be for their welfare and not merely for the disciplining of the man at the center.
Third, we must answer the argument from the patriarchs with the whole of Scripture. When someone points to Abraham and Jacob and David, we should not be embarrassed or defensive. We should simply ask them to read the stories all the way through. Read about Hagar in the wilderness. Read about Leah naming her sons. Read about Joseph in the pit. Read about Hannah weeping and Peninnah provoking her. Read about Abimelech killing his seventy brothers on one stone. Read about Amnon and Tamar and Absalom. Read about Solomon whose wives turned his heart away. And then ask whether this is a pattern of life that God is commending to us. The Bible does not hide what happened in those tents. Those who want to restore the household of the patriarchs need to be prepared to restore all of it, including all the misery that the Scriptures so carefully record.
Fourth, we must hold up the positive picture. It is not enough for us to say what marriage is not. We must show, in our own households and in our teaching, what marriage is meant to be: a union of one man and one woman who become one flesh, who belong to each other, who honor each other as heirs together of the grace of life, and who raise their children in a home free of rivalry and favoritism. Those of us who are not married, and I include myself in this, can still honor and support this picture in the marriages of our friends and our brethren, and can still order our own hopes and desires according to it.
Fifth and finally, we must keep the gospel in view. The reason this matters is not merely that polygamy is illegal, though it is, or that it causes social harm, though it does. The reason this matters is that marriage pictures the relationship between Jesus Christ and His church, a relationship in which one bridegroom gives Himself wholly for one bride. Every faithful marriage between one man and one woman is a small testimony to that coming marriage of the Lamb. Every plural marriage is a distortion of that testimony, telling a false story about the love of God. When we insist on the biblical standard of marriage, we are not being legalistic or merely traditional. We are guarding the picture that God Himself designed to point to the greatest union of all.
From the beginning it was not so, Jesus Christ said. The two shall become one flesh. And at the end, when the marriage of the Lamb has come, the one bride will be presented to the one bridegroom, without spot or wrinkle or any such thing, and there will be no rival wife weeping in the tent, no unloved wife naming her children in hope, no son of the concubine nursing his resentment. That is the future we are waiting for. May we order our households, our teaching, and our hearts in such a way that we point toward it rather than away from it.