Quarreling with Himself: Braxton Bragg and the Neglected Art of Managing Generals

The Anecdote

Ulysses S. Grant was not a man who told stories to settle scores. His Personal Memoirs, written while he was dying of throat cancer in 1884 and 1885, are known for how restrained they are and for how generously they treat former enemies. So the story he tells about Braxton Bragg carries extra weight. It comes in the section on the Chattanooga campaign, where Grant pauses before describing his victory over Bragg at Missionary Ridge to explain the man he had beaten. He relays a story he had heard in the old army:

“On one occasion, when stationed at a post of several companies commanded by a field officer, he was himself commanding one of the companies and at the same time acting as post quartermaster and commissary. He was first lieutenant at the time, but his captain was detached on other duty. As commander of the company he made a requisition upon the quartermaster—himself—for something he wanted. As quartermaster he declined to fill the requisition, and endorsed on the back of it his reasons for so doing. As company commander he responded to this, urging that his requisition called for nothing but what he was entitled to, and that it was the duty of the quartermaster to fill it. As quartermaster he still persisted that he was right. In this condition of affairs Bragg referred the whole matter to the commanding officer of the post. The latter, when he saw the nature of the matter referred, exclaimed: ‘My God, Mr. Bragg, you have quarrelled with every officer in the army, and now you are quarrelling with yourself!'”

One detail of the setup matters. In Grant’s version Bragg holds two offices, company commander and post quartermaster/commissary, and he takes the dispute to a third person, the field officer commanding the post. Retellings often turn that into three offices held at once. The story is actually sharper with only two: Bragg had a superior on hand to settle the matter, and he still could not settle it within himself first.

Grant does not present the story as mockery. Just before it he gives a balanced character sketch. Bragg, he writes, was “a remarkably intelligent and well-informed man, professionally and otherwise. He was also thoroughly upright. But he was possessed of an irascible temper, and was naturally disputatious.” Grant adds that as a subordinate Bragg “was always on the lookout to catch his commanding officer infringing his prerogatives,” and as a post commander he was “equally vigilant to detect the slightest neglect, even of the most trivial order.” The anecdote illustrates the diagnosis. Bragg was not stupid, lazy, or corrupt. His problem was a habit of treating every relationship as a question of rights to be fought over rather than a partnership to be maintained.

Grant was well placed to see the comedy. In the Mexican War he had been regimental quartermaster of the 4th Infantry, and he knew from experience that the quartermaster’s job of saying no to line officers bred friction. Anyone who has held that post knows the tension between the officer who needs something and the officer who must account for it. Bragg’s peculiarity was that he would not let that structural tension be resolved even when both roles sat in one body. He litigated against himself out of devotion to the forms, as though the regulations had a life of their own apart from the people they were supposed to serve.

Whether the incident happened exactly as told cannot be proven. Grant presents it as hearsay from the old army, and stories like this get polished with each retelling. That the story stuck to Bragg in particular, and that officers who knew him found it believable, says more than its literal accuracy would.

The Prewar Reputation

Bragg’s prewar career gave the story its plausibility. He graduated from West Point in 1837, fifth in a class that included Jubal Early, John Sedgwick, and Joseph Hooker, and was commissioned into the artillery. He served in the Seminole War and on garrison duty along the southern coast, and gained a reputation as a rigorous disciplinarian and a sharp critic of superiors.

The Mexican War made him famous. His battery’s performance at Buena Vista in February 1847 helped save Zachary Taylor’s army, and a popular (probably apocryphal) phrase, “A little more grape, Captain Bragg,” made him a national figure. He came out of the war with brevets and public fame. The same period produced the darkest evidence of how his subordinates saw him: in 1847, while he was stationed in the Texas–Mexico theater, someone in his own command tried to kill him by setting off an artillery shell under his cot. He survived without injury. Officers who tell the story often treat it with grim humor, but few men in the old army inspired that kind of attempt.

After the war Bragg kept up his quarrels, including a public feud with the War Department. When Secretary of War Jefferson Davis ordered his battery reassigned to frontier service in the mid-1850s, Bragg treated it as an injury and an insult, and he resigned in 1856. He became a sugar planter near Thibodaux, Louisiana, and served on the state’s Board of Public Works, where his organizational talents had an outlet in levees and drainage. The irony that followed is one of the oddest in Confederate history: Davis, whose decision Bragg had so resented, became his most persistent protector during the war.

The War and the Habit of Contention

Bragg’s Confederate career showed the strengths Grant acknowledged. At Pensacola in 1861 he turned a mass of undisciplined volunteers into one of the best-drilled bodies of troops in the South. At Shiloh he commanded a corps and served as Albert Sidney Johnston’s chief of staff. In June 1862, after P.G.T. Beauregard went on sick leave without permission, Davis gave Bragg command of the army that became the Army of Tennessee. That summer Bragg moved it by rail from Tupelo through Mobile to Chattanooga, a logistical feat for the time, and launched the invasion of Kentucky.

Then the habit Grant described began to dominate. After the drawn and abandoned field at Perryville in October 1862 and the costly retreat from Stones River in January 1863, Bragg did something that captures his character almost as well as the quartermaster story. Stung by newspaper criticism and rumors that his officers had lost faith in him, he sent a circular to his corps and division commanders asking, in effect, whether they had confidence in him and whether he should step down. A man skilled at managing subordinates would never have asked that question in writing. Having asked it, he received honest answers. William J. Hardee replied that his division commanders were unanimous that a change of command was needed. John C. Breckinridge, whose Kentuckians had been destroyed in the January 2 attack Bragg ordered at Stones River, gave a similar answer. Bragg treated the replies not as information but as evidence of conspiracy. He had asked for loyalty in the language of candor, gotten candor, and called it disloyalty.

The pattern continued after Chickamauga in September 1863, the only major Confederate victory in the West. Instead of using the triumph to reconcile his officer corps, Bragg used it to punish. He relieved Leonidas Polk for failing to attack at dawn on September 20 and suspended Thomas Hindman for the failure at McLemore’s Cove before the battle. He took Nathan Bedford Forrest’s troops away and gave them to Joseph Wheeler. Forrest’s surgeon later reported a confrontation in which Forrest called Bragg a “damned scoundrel” and threatened him if Bragg ever crossed his path again. Some historians question the details of that account, but no one doubts that the relationship was over. Davis sent Forrest to an independent command in Mississippi, which tacitly admitted that the two men could not serve together.

The officers struck back with a petition to Davis signed by a dozen generals asking for Bragg’s removal. In October 1863 Davis came to the army’s headquarters near Chattanooga and, in an extraordinary meeting, asked the senior generals in Bragg’s presence what they thought of their commander. James Longstreet, Simon Bolivar Buckner, D.H. Hill, and Benjamin Cheatham each said, in substance, that Bragg should be removed. Davis kept him anyway. D.H. Hill was relieved soon after. Longstreet was sent off toward Knoxville, which removed a large part of the army just before Grant broke the siege of Chattanooga. On November 25, 1863, the Army of Tennessee broke and ran from Missionary Ridge, a position many of its soldiers had believed could not be taken. Bragg resigned his command soon after.

Bragg did not disappear. In February 1864 Davis brought him to Richmond as military adviser to the president, which put the most disliked general in the Confederacy at the center of its command system. In July 1864 Bragg visited the army defending Atlanta, now under Joseph E. Johnston, and his reports helped bring about Johnston’s removal in favor of John Bell Hood. The man who could not keep the trust of his own generals became the instrument by which the president managed, and dismissed, other generals.

The Underestimated Skill

Bragg’s career raises a question that military history, with its attention to maneuver, terrain, and firepower, has often handled poorly. How much did the ability to work with other generals and with political superiors decide the outcome of the war?

Why the Old Army Did Not Teach It

The prewar Regular Army was tiny, roughly sixteen thousand men spread across coastal forts and frontier posts. Officers knew one another personally, often from West Point, and the formal hierarchy settled most disputes. The academy curriculum emphasized engineering, mathematics, and fortification under Dennis Hart Mahan, not the political management of coalitions. An officer could rise to captain or major without ever negotiating with a governor, persuading a congressman, or calming a jealous peer whose cooperation he needed but could not order.

The Civil War destroyed that world. Armies of a hundred thousand men were raised through state governments, and colonels and brigadiers owed their commissions to governors, senators, and party networks. Political generals such as Nathaniel Banks, Benjamin Butler, John McClernand, and Franz Sigel on the Union side, or John B. Floyd and Henry Wise on the Confederate side, held commands because they could deliver voters, ethnic communities, or regional loyalty. Newspapers carried accounts of quarrels within days. The telegraph put the president’s attention in constant contact with the commander’s tent. Congress’s Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War investigated Union generals; Confederate state governors such as Georgia’s Joseph Brown and North Carolina’s Zebulon Vance guarded their troops and supplies against Richmond. A general who could not manage these relationships might win battles and still lose his army.

The Union: Failures and One Master

George B. McClellan is the classic Union example of a gifted organizer undone by his inability to work with his political superior. He built the Army of the Potomac into a formidable instrument, but his contempt for Lincoln, whom he called “the original gorilla” in a private letter, along with his habit of keeping his plans from the administration and his open political ambitions, turned a working relationship into a mutual siege. On one notorious occasion he went to bed while the president waited in his parlor. Lincoln’s patience was remarkable, but it was not endless.

Joseph Hooker rose partly by undermining his commander, Ambrose Burnside. Burnside’s attempt to purge Hooker and others through General Orders No. 8 in January 1863 collapsed when Lincoln refused to approve it and gave Hooker the army instead. Lincoln’s letter to Hooker of January 26, 1863, is one of the best documents in American history on the management of a general. He praised Hooker’s courage and skill, then rebuked him directly: “I have heard, in such way as to believe it, of your recently saying that both the Army and the Government needed a Dictator. Of course it was not for this, but in spite of it, that I have given you the command. Only those generals who gain successes, can set up dictators. What I now ask of you is military success, and I will risk the dictatorship.” In those few sentences the president warned the general that the habits of insubordination he had used against Burnside could be turned against him.

John Pope’s short tenure in Virginia in 1862 showed another failure. His bombastic opening proclamation insulted the eastern troops he was supposed to lead, and his feud with Fitz John Porter after Second Manassas ended in Porter’s court-martial and a dispute that lasted decades.

Against this background, Grant’s political skill stands out, and it is still often underrated because he made it look effortless. After Fort Donelson in 1862, Henry Halleck nearly sidelined him over reports of insubordination and rumored drinking. Grant responded not with a public quarrel but with patient, factual correspondence, and he was restored. He kept the patronage of Congressman Elihu Washburne without becoming his creature. He built a lasting partnership with William T. Sherman, who in turn talked Grant out of leaving the army in the dark spring of 1862. He tolerated John McClernand, a political general with direct access to Lincoln, for months, and relieved him in June 1863 only when McClernand published a self-congratulatory order to the press that gave Grant a clean regulatory reason. Bragg would have fought McClernand on day one and lost the fight with Washington. Grant waited until McClernand handed him the ground on which to win.

The most delicate test came in 1864, when Grant, as general-in-chief, chose to travel with the Army of the Potomac while leaving George Meade in formal command. The arrangement was awkward and produced friction, but it held. Grant mostly issued his direction through Meade, protected Meade’s dignity, and stepped in at decisive moments, such as backing Philip Sheridan’s demand in May 1864 to go after J.E.B. Stuart’s cavalry. With Lincoln, Grant practiced a quiet strategy of not asking for what he did not need and not explaining what the president did not need to know, and Lincoln valued him for it. Grant’s patience had limits: in December 1864 he came close to relieving George Thomas at Nashville for delay and had sent John Logan to replace him before Thomas attacked and destroyed Hood’s army. But even Grant’s impatience worked through the system rather than against it.

The Confederacy: Lee and the Others

On the Confederate side, Robert E. Lee was as skilled a manager of his president as Grant was of his. Lee served as Davis’s adviser in the spring of 1862 and understood Davis’s sensitivity, his need to be consulted, and his tendency to take differences of opinion as personal criticism. Lee’s letters to Davis are models of deference that still steered policy: he proposed, explained, flattered where needed, and seldom confronted directly. With his own lieutenants Lee was equally careful. When Stonewall Jackson and A.P. Hill fell into a bitter quarrel, Jackson arresting Hill and Hill demanding a court of inquiry, Lee worked to keep the dispute from reaching formal judgment and kept both men in the field. Lee was willing to leave a quarrel unsettled if settling it would cost him a good officer. Bragg could not leave even his own internal quarrel unsettled.

Joseph E. Johnston was Bragg’s opposite in temperament but shared his disastrous relationship with authority. Johnston’s resentment of his ranking among the Confederacy’s full generals in 1861, his habit of keeping his plans from Davis, and his reluctance to promise anything poisoned the relationship with the president beyond repair. When Davis asked him in July 1864 how he planned to defend Atlanta, Johnston’s evasive answer, together with Hood’s confidential letters to Richmond criticizing his superior and Bragg’s own report from the field, led to his removal on the eve of the city’s crisis. Beauregard, after First Manassas, damaged his standing with Davis through a report that took credit and assigned blame in ways Davis took personally. Hood rose by cultivating Richmond while undermining Johnston, then led his army to destruction at Franklin and Nashville. Political skill without military judgment was as dangerous as the reverse.

What Bragg Teaches

Bragg’s case is instructive because he was not incompetent in the narrow sense. He was organized, honest, a disciplinarian who could build an army, and in Kentucky and at Chickamauga he showed real strategic imagination. Historians have debated him for decades. Grady McWhiney and Judith Hallock’s two-volume biography, Thomas Connelly’s studies of the Army of Tennessee, Steven Woodworth’s Jefferson Davis and His Generals, and Earl Hess’s more sympathetic 2016 biography all wrestle with how such a capable administrator could preside over such a dysfunctional command. Most of the answer lies in Grant’s diagnosis. Bragg treated command as a series of jurisdictional disputes to be won rather than relationships to be maintained. He asked for loyalty and received candor; he demanded obedience and received petitions; he punished subordinates after his only great victory, and at Missionary Ridge his army did not stand.

The connection between the quartermaster anecdote and the Army of Tennessee is more than metaphor. An army is a system of offices held by people who must yield to one another. The quartermaster must sometimes fill a requisition he doubts; the company commander must sometimes accept a refusal he resents; the general must sometimes swallow an insult from a subordinate he needs and court a president he dislikes. The officers who succeeded in the Civil War, Grant and Lee above all, understood that the formal hierarchy was only the skeleton of command, and that the muscle was trust earned through patience and sometimes through deliberate silence. Bragg understood the skeleton perfectly. As the old army’s story put it, he never learned that the hardest settlement is sometimes the one that has to be reached within oneself before anyone else can be asked to judge it.

Unknown's avatar

About nathanalbright

I'm a person with diverse interests who loves to read. If you want to know something about me, just ask.
This entry was posted in American Civil War, American History, History, Military History and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply