Book Review: Guide To The Collapse Of Yugoslavia 1991-1999

Guide To The Collapse Of Yugoslavia 1991-1999, by Alastair Finlan

Among the free books on history I was able to download and read was this gem, which takes a distinct approach to the Balkan conflicts that reduces the emphasis on the Ottoman period (particularly the often-cited battle of Kossovo in 1389 [1]) and instead looks at the origin of the collapse of Yugoslavia in the events of the Balkan Wars as well as the world wars. In fact, it may be argued (albeit implicitly) from what this book discusses that the real flaw in the collapse of Yugoslavia was its creation in the first place, seeing as it put together groups of people that did not particularly want to be together in order to appease the interests of Serbians after WWI in order to punish the Austro-Hungarian Empire for its errors [2]. Once the restraining hand of Tito was removed, the failure of the leaders of Serbia in particular to avoid seeking cheap popularity through appeals to ethnic populism lead to growing division and the politicization of the Yugoslav army (always a dangerous sign for lovers of freedom and the well-being of ordinary people), and the collapse of Yugoslavia followed rapidly from there, starting with Slovenia and rapidly progressing to Croatia, Bosnia-Herzogovina, Macedonia, and even Kosovo. This particular book stops with the Kosovo war of 1999, and so it does not cover the Macedonian troubles with its own Albanian minority nor the independence of Montenegro, which took place after 2000 and are outside the scope of this book, but which continue the book’s general themes concerning the collapse of Greater Serbia. Likewise, the book tends to minimize the importance of Russia’s alliance with Serbia, which has only come more important since 2000.

This particular book takes a largely chronological approach, which also happens to be a largely geographical approach, as few particular historical matters contain the domino effect that we can see most notably in the collapse of Yugoslavia. It was Slovenia, distant from Serbian power and close to the burgeoning European Unit, that was the first to separate, with only a short conflict, as Serbia was unable to project much power that far from its core. Croatia had sought to separate but was faced with a lengthy conflict against Serb-supported separatists that took over large territories because of Serbia’s military superiority (until the support of the United States for Croatian sovereignty). This was even more the case in Bosnia-Herzogovina, which had a more cosmopolitan identity reflecting its far more divided identity. After years of destruction and immense damage to Bosnia’s infrastructure, a fragile peace was enforced through NATO military might that remains to this day. After this, conflict in the former Yugoslavia moved to Kosovo, with its Albanian majority as well as its importance to nationalist Serbs because of its historic importance. The book does an excellent job in discussing the failures of the complex international approach as well as the complex players within the former Yugoslavia, pointing out British failure in particular under John Major’s government and a great deal of nuance and even contradiction in many of the governments and nations involved in the effort, as well as the role of Milosevic in using Serb minorities in Croatia and Bosnia and Kosovo as tools for his own political ambitions.

Among the more touching aspects of this particular book are the occasional commentaries on particularly noteworthy people in the long struggle for peace in the former Yugoslavia as it fractured into its various quarreling constituent parts. One of the people discussed in these sections was an articulate and very insightful young lady from Sarajevo, Zlata Filipovic, whose diary gave her, her insights as a humane and intelligent young lady, and the plight of her suffering people some much needed attention, allowing her and her family to escape the horrors of that besieged city and a new life in Paris. Not everyone got to escape, but it is sad when ordinary people possess great insight but political leaders are mired in moral cowardice dealing with corrupt criminals and violent murderers, unable to tap into that wisdom because they only like dealing with other people of their kind. The lengthy humanitarian crisis in the former Yugoslavia is just one example of many where this lack of insight and moral courage on the part of political leaders is apparent, and it is a very valid one in examining the contemporary moral failures when it comes to treating criminals and terrorists like responsible parties for international dialogue and neglecting the plight of the common people whose lives they harm because of their evil and folly. As the author points out sadly, the lessons of Yugoslavia’s collapse appear not to have been learned or remembered well.

[1] See, for example:

https://edgeinducedcohesion.wordpress.com/2014/06/02/book-review-the-balkan-wars/

[2] https://edgeinducedcohesion.wordpress.com/2014/06/28/book-review-a-mad-catastrophe/

About nathanalbright

I'm a person with diverse interests who loves to read. If you want to know something about me, just ask.
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Christianity, History, International Relations, Military History and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Book Review: Guide To The Collapse Of Yugoslavia 1991-1999

  1. jj says:

    Well Slovenia was working with Germany and Austria for 10 years towards succession. Janez Jansa was well-known to be a NATO spy. Also the British paper The Guardian, even came out, after the wars ended (around 2000), with a report that the British sold and shipped millions worth of military communication equipment to Slovenia just before the outbreak of the war. It was done covertly behind the Yugoslav government’s back and was even signed by a British politician who was publicly saying he wanted Yugoslavia to stay together. Yet his actions are proof his words were lies.

    Also read this written while the wars were still happening:

    Yugoslavia
    from the book

    The CIAs Greatest Hits

    The bloodshed and chaos that have engulfed Yugoslavia since its breakup have been portrayed as the inevitable result of bottled-up ethnic tensions. But there’s considerable evidence that both the breakup and the warfare were encouraged by Western intelligence services-including Germany’s BND, the successor to the Gehlen Org.

    Germany’s interests in the region date to World War II, when the Bosnians and Croats allied with the Nazis against the Serbs, who the Nazis regarded as untermenschen (subhumans). After Germany reunified in 1989, it began to take a more expansionist attitude toward Eastern Europe, and Yugoslavia in particular. In 1990, it urged the Bush administration to help it dismantle Yugoslavia.

    Bush was happy to comply, since the US had longstanding plans to overthrow Yugoslavia’s government. Yugoslavia had recently renounced the market-oriented “shock treatment” prescribed for it, which had been causing social unrest, so it was a prime candidate for further destabilization.

    The Germans encouraged Croatia to secede from Yugoslavia, and Bosnia soon followed. Germany immediately recognized the new nations, forcing the hand of the European Community, which had wanted to take a more cautious approach. The new Croatian state adopted the flag and anthem of its WWII Nazi puppet regime-and, in some cases, the same personnel.

    Virulently fascist Croats had long been active in the World Anti-Communist League and other exile groups nurtured by the CIA. Many Eastern European Nazis had gone on to work with the CIA, either in the US or in covert operations abroad. With the collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe, many of these aging chickens came home to roost. Neofascist movements are active in Lithuania, Hungary and Romania, as well as in much of Western Europe (notably Italy).

    Despite an official arms embargo against Croatia and Bosnia, Western powers immediately began covertly arming them, which would have been impossible without the knowledge and acquiescence of the CIA and the BND. Mercenaries from Britain, Germany and the US are said to be serving alongside the Croat militias-a sure sign of an ongoing covert operation. In fact, in 1994, the CIA opened a new base in Albania to monitor troop movements and “potential targets.”

    http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/CIA%20Hits/Yugoslavia_CIAHits.html

  2. Pingback: Book Review: Guide To The American Revolution 1774-1783 | Edge Induced Cohesion

  3. Pingback: Book Review: Lord, Teach Us To Pray | Edge Induced Cohesion

  4. Pingback: Non-Book Review: A Handful Of Bullets | Edge Induced Cohesion

  5. Pingback: Book Review: Ethnic Conflict In World Politics | Edge Induced Cohesion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s